Thinking about adding signed memorabilia to your collection or submitting an autograph for grading? In this guide, we’ll break down the critical differences between authenticated autographs and raw signatures, how they impact collectible value, and why working with a PSA Authorized Dealer like Card Collector Club can protect both your wallet and your investment.
What Is an Autograph Authentication?
Autograph authentication is the process of verifying that a signature is genuine and not forged, auto-penned, or printed. Reputable companies like PSA employ trained experts who analyze:
- Ink properties and pressure
- Signature flow and pen lifts
- Comparisons to known authentic examples
- Paper or material age and consistency
When confirmed as authentic, the item receives a tamper-evident seal or Certificate of Authenticity (COA) with a unique serial number logged in the company’s online database.
What Is a Raw Signature?
A raw signature is any autograph that has not been reviewed, authenticated, or encapsulated by a trusted third-party grader. While it may be real, there’s no objective proof, leaving buyers and sellers open to uncertainty.
Many collectors unknowingly purchase raw autographs with the assumption they’re real, only to find later they’re forged or misrepresented.
Why Authentication Matters for Collectors and Investors
Let’s be clear: in today’s market, authentication separates casual collectibles from investment-grade memorabilia. Here’s how:
Value Boost
| Item | Raw Value | Authenticated Value |
| Michael Jordan Signed 8×10 | $150–$300 | $500–$1,200 (PSA) |
| Tom Brady Signed Rookie Card | $1,500–$2,000 | $4,000+ (PSA slabbed) |
| Pikachu Illustrator Signed Card | ??? | Unverifiable unless authenticated |
(Based on recent eBay and Goldin Auctions listings)
A verified autograph can increase an item’s value by 2x–5x or more.
Fraud Protection
In our experience, forged signatures are rampant in the collectibles space. Especially with popular subjects like Kobe Bryant, Stan Lee, or vintage athletes, counterfeiters often use aged ink, pre-printed designs, or fake COAs.
Authentication gives buyers peace of mind, and sellers a reputation for honesty.
Collector Trust and Resale Liquidity
An authenticated signature from PSA builds buyer trust. Raw autographs? Not so much. Whether you’re consigning through an auction house or listing online, authenticated pieces move faster—and with fewer questions.
The PSA Advantage
As a PSA Authorized Dealer, we trust PSA as the most recognized name in autograph authentication. Here’s why:
- Industry-Leading Experts with decades of experience
- Secure encapsulation and COA systems
- Global database for verification
- Preferred by major auction houses and collectors
- High resale value across sports, entertainment, and TCG markets
Working with Card Collector Club, you gain access to priority authentication services, expert guidance, and a streamlined submission process backed by the hobby’s most trusted name.
FAQs: Autograph Authentication
Can I sell raw autographs?
Yes—but expect a lower selling price, limited buyer interest, and possible returns due to authenticity disputes.
Is authentication necessary for personalized autographs?
Even inscriptions like “To John” or “Best Wishes” can benefit from authentication if the subject is high-value or deceased (e.g., Kobe Bryant, Stan Lee).
How can I tell if an autograph is fake?
Common red flags include:
- Too-perfect placement or ink
- Absence of natural pen pressure
- No certificate or a generic one from an unknown source
- Mass-produced “signed” merchandise
When in doubt, authenticate it.
Raw vs. Authenticated: Summary Table
Absolutely. Here is the highlighted text presented in a table format:
| Feature | Raw Signature | Authenticated Signature (PSA) |
| Verified Authenticity | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Resale Value | 💲 Lower | 💰 Higher |
| Buyer Trust | ⚠️ Questionable | ✅ Trusted |
| Tamper-Evident Protection | ❌ None | ✅ Encapsulated |
| Auction & Marketplace Acceptance | ⚠️ Limited | ✅ Widely Accepted |
Why Submit Through Card Collector Club
As collectors ourselves, we understand the value and emotion behind every signed item. That’s why we go the extra mile:
- Pre-authentication evaluations
- Secure packaging and tracking
- PSA submission access
- Transparent guidance on signature condition and placement
Whether you’re verifying a vintage baseball, signed Pokémon card, or celebrity photo, our team helps ensure it’s properly authenticated—and maximized for value.
Start Your Authentication Submission Here
Contact Our Experts
Final Thoughts: Don’t Leave Value to Chance
A signature is only as good as the proof behind it. While raw autographs can carry personal significance, they don’t offer the same protection, liquidity, or market credibility as authenticated pieces.
In today’s investment-minded hobby, autograph authentication is no longer optional—it’s essential. And when you work with a trusted PSA Authorized Dealer like Card Collector Club, you’re putting your collection in the hands of professionals who understand the process and share your passion.